A smartwatch can list dozens of activity modes, but only a few may matter to you. Before choosing between Garmin and Fitbit, write down your main activities: running, gym sessions, cycling, swimming, walking, golf or general daily movement. Then compare the model specifications against that list.
The Garmin Approach S12 name points shoppers towards Garmin’s activity-specific range, while the Garmin Instinct E 45mm Black appears positioned as a more rugged-looking Garmin option from the title. The Fitbit Versa 4 Graphite, by contrast, sits as a Versa model in the Fitbit range. Those cues are useful, but they are not enough on their own. Check the sport mode details, water resistance wording, sensor list and app compatibility in the product listing.
If you only do casual workouts, a simpler interface may matter more than advanced metrics. If you follow structured training or spend a lot of time outdoors, prioritise GPS clarity, battery claims and sport-tracking detail. The best smartwatch is the one that records the activities you actually do without adding complexity you will ignore.